DPC ·
Ask the jewelers.
From INSTORE’s 2026 Big Survey of more than 500 independent jewelers:
“Three-quarters of jewelers who could say (75%) report that the 0.50–1.50 carat natural bridal range is shrinking in their stores, as customers trade up to bigger lab-grown stones or step further up into natural. Among stores that track their engagement sales, lab-grown accounts for more than half at 58%, and more than three-quarters at 36%.
One jeweler says customers often put it this way: “I want the 2-, 3-, or 4-carat look I love, but I’m not spending $20,000–$40,000 just because it’s a natural diamond.” Social pressure plays a part too. “All their friends have 3 carats!!” another wrote.
Asked why natural has lost market share, the largest group (28%) said consumers simply don’t seem to care about the differences. Another 18% blamed decades of inflated pricing by De Beers and the traditional supply chain.”
That’s independent jewelers talking, not lab-grown producers.
Customers don’t care about the differences because, apart from origin, there aren’t any. A lab-grown diamond is identical to a mined one down to its atomic structure, and you need lab equipment to tell them apart. Offered a billion-year backstory or a bigger diamond for the same money, most prefer the diamond.
