Skip to content

Myths & Truth

Myth 9

Mining does good for local communities.

Truth

Mining activities result in an"extraction of wealth from land that paradoxically does not produce wealth for the local populations who remain poor."His Holiness Pope Francis

Mining revenues are not proof of community benefit. Show what reaches workers and local communities.

Who Benefits from Mining Revenue?

  • Wealth outflow: Claims about diamond revenues should show how much reaches the workers and communities where diamonds are mined. Revenue for traders and mining companies is not proof of local prosperity. [1, 2]
  • Low pay and debt: Artisanal and small-scale miners often work in hazardous conditions for meager wages, sometimes trapped in cycles of debt bondage and poverty. [1, 2]
  • Broken promises: Local governments and mining companies frequently fail to deliver legally required compensation, infrastructure investments, or community development funds. [1, 2]

Environmental and Community Destruction

  • Water contamination: Heavy processing uses vast amounts of water and pollutes local rivers and groundwater with toxic runoff, destroying safe drinking and farming supplies for residents. [1, 2]
  • Loss of livelihood: Clearing forests and land for mining destroys traditional hunting grounds, sacred ancestral sites, and agricultural land, stripping communities of their food sources. [1, 2]
  • Long-term hazards: Abandoned mine pits fill with stagnant water after operations cease, creating breeding grounds for malaria and leaving lasting ecological scars. [1]

Related: How the wealth from Sierra Leone’s diamonds fails to enrich local communities